Thursday, June 6, 2013

Cyberbullies: Antagonizing Others One Keystroke at a Time


We have all heard about bullies – people who make it their life’s work to ensure the lives of others are miserable.  The bullies of the past relied on spoken word to antagonize their victims.  The bullies of today, on the other hand, are equipped with the use of social media, online chat rooms, and blogs through the use of the worldwide web.

In terms of the use of internet for communication Bynum (2008) explains that “information and communication technology (ICT) has affected – in both good ways and bad ways – community life, family life, human relationships, education, careers, freedom, and democracy” (http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/ethics-computer/).  While the internet is a great tool for many of us in our daily lives – everyday there are individuals being persecuted via the worldwide web.  

No walls are too high…no boundaries are too far…cyberbullying can happen to anyone, at anytime.  “Cyberbullying occurs “when technology is misused to threaten, harass, humiliate or embarrass victims.  From nuisance phone calls to bogus websites, the victims of cyberbullies can be targeted with little effort and minimal cost to the bully” (Rogers, 2010, p. 7). 

When researching cyberbullying the information I came across was all in relation to children being bullied via the web.  Many children who experience cyberbullying both academically and emotionally – some children suffer so greatly they choose to take their own lives (Holladay, 2010, p. 42).  Cyberbullying, as with any other form of bullying, can result in low self-esteem and feelings of decreased self-worth (Patchin and Hinduja, 2010).

 Cyberbullying can range from pictures on a website, to derogatory Facebook statuses or tweets or even blogs.  I would even include pictures taken by paparazzi and then shared on the internet as a form of cyberbullying. These forms of shared information could be deemed libel if it is “defamation by written or printed words, pictures, or in any form other than by spoken words or gestures; the act or crime of publishing it; anything that is defamatory or that maliciously or damagingly misrepresents” (http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/libel?s=t).

Betz (2011) explains “a particularly threatening feature of cyberbullies for victims is that they can operate in “virtual” anonymity” (p. 283).  She goes on to explain that teaching kids what is sharable information paired with how to be respectful to others is the key to ending cyberbullying (Betz, 2011). 
 
No one is regulating what is posted in cyberspace (Patchin and Hinduja, 2010) – but the invitation to commit cyberbullying would still exist even if there was regulation.  For centuries rules have been broken and for centuries to come this will remain. 

Remember the mother who cyberbullied a girl her daughter attended school with?  She created a fictitious profile of a boy on MySpace (how long ago was that trend?!) and reportedly told the girl “the world would be a better place without her” (Meredith, 2010, p. 311).  Meredith (2010) explains that although the mother violated the MySpace Terms of Service she was later acquitted.  A child lost her life due to cyberbullying – and the woman who pushed the child over the edge walks away.

The belief is that “empowering educators with the tools to inform students and parents about how to use ever-changing technology wisely is key” (Meredith, 2010, p. 334).  First people must be open to the education and willing to see a different point of view. I have seen firsthand parents on Facebook posting status updates – being a cyberbully. What kind of role model is that parent being to their children who are their “friends” on Facebook? 

Many naïve people still believe everything they read on the worldwide web to be truth.  The only truth is that whether factual or not – one should not base all claims on one source of information.  Sources and perspectives help us to look beyond our own biases or walls we put up for ourselves. 

Whether you are a fan of the WWE or not, they are making strides to end bullying (http://www.wwe.com/). They paired with The Creative Coalition in April 2011 to start the program Be a STAR – Show Tolerance and Respect.  “The mission of Be a STAR is to ensure a positive and equitable social environment for everyone regardless of age, race, religion, or sexual orientation through grassroots efforts beginning with education and awareness” (http://community.wwe.com/diversity/programs/be-star).  As of June 2013 30,000 people have pledged through the WWE website to end bullying.  The superstars and divas are so committed to end bullying that they visit “2-3 schools or community centers per month to speak with students about bullying issues including sharing their own personal stories” (http://community.wwe.com/diversity/programs/be-star). 

A great website for parents regarding what bullying is:  http://www.stompoutbullying.org/aboutbullying.php – there is also a chat line, phone number, and personal stories which help make an impact on parents and kids alike.

A strategy I have used to help me avoid posting/sending anything which could be perceived as hurtful is to wait 24 hours. I learned this from a friend – she explained there was an email she wanted to send but when she read it to her husband he said “wait 24 hours – if you re-read that tomorrow and you still feel the same way then you can hit submit.” Best advice I have received! It is my mantra – if I am unsure I simply wait 24 hours. Whether it is an email, a blog post, a Facebook status, or a text message – when in doubt, wait 24 hours.

"Never be bullied into silence. Never allow yourself to be made a victim. Accept no one's definition of your life, but define yourself."
~Harvey Fierstein


References not hyperlinked:

Betz, C. (2011). Cyberbullying: The virtual threat. Journal of Pediatric Nursing, 26(4), p. 283-284.

Holladay, J. (2010). Teaching Tolerance. Southern Poverty Law Center.

Meredith, J. (2010). Combating cyberbullying: Emphasizing education over criminalization. Federal Communications Law Journal, 63, p. 311-340.
Patchin, J., & Hinduja, S. (2010). Cyberbullying and self-esteem. Journal of School Health, 80(12), p. 614-621.

Rogers, V. (2010). Cyberbullying: Activities to help children and teens to stay safe in a texting, twittering, social networking world. London, Great Britain: Jessica Kingsley Publishers.



9 comments:

  1. Excellent post on an important subject. Check out Ashley's blog in the other class section - one of our fellow students had a very personal example of cyberbullying impacting his niece.

    http://ashleystechnologyadventure.blogspot.com/2013/06/cyberbullying.html

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Britt! This is an important subject that we do not give enough attention to in order to really make an impact! Thanks for sharing Ashley's blog - it was interesting to see his perspective and heart wrenching to read about his personal experience.

      Delete
  2. Sarah,

    Thanks for your informative and thoughtful post. I have to admit that I am quite naive on cyber-bullying as I am not aware of this happening to my daughters. Or they avoided telling me for fear of what I would do to the bully.

    However, recently there have been two or three cases in the local area that have gotten a lot of press due to the fact that the victim's took their lives. These very sad stories have made some people stand up and act.

    Before the digital age, bullies were real people who accosted you. You knew the bully and find ways to either avoid them or stand up to them. Now the bullies are more likely to be anonymous as people can create false identities and hide behind their avatars.

    You are also finding that people that would never act this way in public are more embolden to bully, haze, or lash out on the internet. I would state that technology has made bullying easier to do from a far as you may never truly see the effects of your actions, until it is too late.

    When it is children being the bully, I hold the parent responsible for their actions. It could be that they are just copying action and attitudes from the parents or that they are given too much freedom with out consequences for their actions.

    When my daughters first got into social media, my wife told them that they had to friend her so that she could make sure that they were acting responsibly and also being safe as we didn't want them to give away too much information.

    As they got older, she reduced her reviews and now she is still a friend but really as a friend vice the parental monitor. Parents need to see that we don't have to be helicopters and hover over our children day in and day out but that by our actions we teach them right and wrong ways to act.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you for your response! The web definitely makes it easier to bully and many people do hide behind their avatars - to me that is simply being a coward! In my opinion if you cannot stand up to someone and tell them how you feel or what you want to say - then it should not be said in any form.

      I think it's great that your wife made your daughters friend her on Facebook. It is a great way to monitor their activity without being so overbearing that they hide things from you. For example, my parents never gave us a curfew - they simply told us to be safe and always call if we needed a ride. Because of this trust in me and the fact that they granted me the freedom to choose when I came home I was always in by 11pm - regardless of the night or what was going on. If I was going to be late I would call. I had respect for my parents and wanted to make them proud - so I avoided parties, drinking, and other various things. Some would say I am an old soul - I grew up much faster than my peers and I was okay with that! Thank God, in fact, because that is what has helped me to have the drive and the will to get this far in my life at such a young age.

      Delete
  3. I too have had a first hand experience with cyber bullying. There was also an incident of cyber stalking. Some one told me its as easy as closing down the Facebook. That is not as easy for some as it seems. Our family has a very active Facebook forum and we are busy just keeping up with one another. It has brought our family closer for sure. My dear cousin got her daughters Facebook login ( through Keystrokes) and monitored what was happening. She was younger than 18 and my cousin felt she should monitor and that monitoring use is responsible parenting as it creates an opportunity to teach. My cousin was mortified when she found her own daughter was bullying someone. What do you do as a parent of a child doing what would break your heart. She was trying to protect her daughter and understood that protecting meant stopping her bullying. I think this should be mandatory that parents are co-owners of accounts( instead of having the older than 18 where one can cheat). Just like check books, you are joint owners. My sister started doing this when her daughter wanted a site and she is teaching her daughter appropriate use.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I too experienced this in our family. My cousin was watching her daughter's Facebook and found that SHE was the bully. Talk about alarming. She used it as a teaching moment but it made me think parents should co-own Facebook accounts. My sister, after this happened reviewed all my nieces posts and for a week told her she wanted to approve all posts and all posts on her walls by others. It was quite an interesting exercise. We need to teach our children about the internet and using it just as we teach them to drive. Its a tool that can be great, but used wrong can create havoc, even causing people pain.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Although I am not yet a parent I cannot imagine what that must have been like for your cousin realizing her daughter was the bully. That is definitely a teachable moment because often times bullies have issues with insecurity so finding this out probably helped your niece. It is so sad to me that people try to make others lives miserable. The old saying 'why can't we all just get along' is my mantra regarding this issue. I realize we are human beings and we will have differences of opinion but in the grand scheme of things in the end we are all children of God -- imagine how our Father feels!

      Delete
  5. Thank you for the resources and the great 24 hour rule. When we have found strategies that work for us and are willing to share them with kids in the form of a think-aloud, they discover that others face similar challenges, but have also found ways not to be sucked into "bad" behaviors.

    One of the issues that makes cyberbullying harder to deal with is that it can happen anonymously. Recently a person set up a twitter account using a screen name only to attack student athletes in the conference in which I coach. Almost overnight the twitter feed had over a hundred followers. These followers added fuel to the fire by being bystanders to the cruel comments and their following showed the writer that they had an audience and support. When talking with my student-athletes, they didn't originally think of it in this way. They started following the twitter feed in hopes they wouldn't be the next target. As educators, parents, adults, and community leaders we have to be willing to have critical conversations with kids about the impact of using technology to hurt others and the impact of being a silent bystander. At a conference I attended Kevin Honeycutt, a technology expert, pointed out that we don't just send our kids out to the playground unsupervised. We must look at social media as a playground and help teach the rules as well as monitor what is happening and intervene when needed.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I can see where the student athletes thought that by following the twitter feed it might help them to avoid the same treatment. This happens everywhere - if you blend in with the crowd it makes you harder to be a target for someone. I cannot say I blame them for their thought - but you are right we do need to be willing to have crucial conversations about what is right and what is wrong. The idea of the web as a playground is an interesting concept - it makes sense. Just like we would teach kids to play fair on the playground the same is true for the web. Great comments!

      Delete